top of page

Huracán Maria

Writer: Elizabeth A. Geier
Elizabeth A. Geier
Dec 20, 2017
5 min read

Updated: Dec 22, 2017

Argumentative/Persuasive writing piece: helping Puerto Rico recover from Hurricane Maria

The hurricane in Puerto Rico left immense suffering for the nation. On September 20, 2017 Hurricane Maria — a powerful Category 4 hurricane with 150 mph winds —struck Puerto Rico, bisecting the entire island and drenching it with feet of rain. The happenings since the disaster have been truly catastrophic for Puerto Rico. The US has a duty to help Puerto Rico during this humanitarian crisis.


The current state of Puerto Rico, as of October 16, 2017, there is still little power on the island, there is still no water to drink or bathe in or to flush toilets. There is limited food and cell service, and dozens of remote villages have been completely cut off from everything for weeks. Getting relief to the country is very important. After a hurricane, emergency managers have to bring resources to the site, and then distribute them to people who need them. In the case of Puerto Rico, both parts are challenging because it’s an island in the middle of the ocean. The disaster relief group, FEMA noted what they can done for hurricane relief. They have deployed 330 staffers from the Department of Health and Human Services; Army Corps of Engineers staff; EPA officials; and a range of Department of Defense assistance, including helicopters and planes. A depot has been established to gather goods. A FEMA spokeswoman tweeted Tuesday afternoon that the agency had provided 4 million meals, 6 million liters of water, and thousands of tarps and rolls of roof sheeting. All of what FEMA is providing is wonderful for the people of Puerto Rico. They are helping the suffering men, women, and children on the island after such devastation.


These pictures show the devastation in Puerto Rico.


Look at the ruins that were once people’s home. Everyone’s faces are in shock, seeing everything they knew scattered to the winds. It is quite heartbreaking. The sad thing is, they have to keep living in these conditions, trying to survive.



The opposing side facts of Puerto Rico are some reasons why Americans don’t find it imperative to give aid to the nation. Arguments could be that Puerto Rico was already in shambles before the hurricane and now helping them would further their debt and economic problems. There are facts to show truth in that claim. The Washington Post reported that Congress has not received, and does not expect to receive, a new request for disaster-relief funding from the Trump administration until mid-October. But that doesn’t necessarily mean the federal government is not responsible for providing aid. FEMA has money on hand for upfront costs, and there’s no indication that relief is slow because FEMA is short on cash. Congressional appropriations after a disaster offer a strong signal of national support, but they’re unlikely to make a quick difference in conditions on the ground. It is also true that Puerto Rico’s economy has been in trouble for at least a decade. The website, The Economist, discussed the long-term damage, “Before the storm, Puerto Rico already faced an economic collapse. Having borrowed too much, and seen its economy shrink almost every year since 2005, the island commenced bankruptcy-like proceedings in May.” With all the natural disasters happening in the states and abroad, President Trump weighed in on Puerto Rico, seeming to take the opposition of limiting aid. Trump tweeted:

“Texas & Florida are doing great but Puerto Rico, which was already suffering from broken infrastructure & massive debt, is in deep trouble... It's old electrical grid, which was in terrible shape, was devastated. Much of the Island was destroyed, with billions of dollars owed to Wall Street and the banks which, sadly, must be dealt with. Food, water and medical are top priorities - and doing well.” –Donald Trump

It’s true that years of deferred maintenance, due to lack of funds, made Puerto Rico’s electric grid vulnerable, but it’s unclear how the nation’s debts factor into its immediate recovery. In the long run, those debts will mean that federal assistance is all the more important. Even if President Trump doesn’t seem to eager to help the suffering nation, other government officials can, without hands-on presidential involvement.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency is providing help, relying in part on the $15.3 billion in funding that Congress allocated for disaster relief earlier in September, after Hurricanes Harvey and Irma struck Texas and Florida, respectively. But the island’s governor, Ricardo Roselló, is in no doubt that more help is needed. Otherwise, he says, the island faces a “humanitarian crisis”. He also said, “Make no mistake — this is a humanitarian disaster involving 3.4 million US citizens,” this was said the Monday after Maria hit.


The bottom line is that people are in immense suffering and hardships. It can be difficult to connect with a different country effected by the hurricanes because media coverage in the Texas disaster and in Florida, but other nations need assistance. The website, Vox, describes some things about Puerto Rico that most Americans don’t know.

  1. 3.4 million US citizens live in Puerto Rico, and they are entitled to the same government response as any state.

  2. Hurricane Maria was like a 50-mile-wide tornado that made a direct hit on the island.

  3. There’s not enough water or food on the island. Power will be out for months in some places.

  4. Puerto Rico’s economy is in shambles, and the storm will make it worse. The lack of power, fuel, water is causing horrific conditions for hospitals, increasing illnesses and worse, death.

  5. Experts believe the death toll could reach into the hundreds. So far the toll has found 81 deaths confirmed by officials as linked to the storm and reports of another 450 deaths without a known cause of death. People are in desperate need for resources and help.

  6. You can help. Here are list of charity and relief efforts. (go to link to see available websites fro disaster relief)

Seeing this list alone can show Americans and anyone else questioning whether to give more assistance to Puerto Rico. The island is in dire straits. Most of the island is without electricity. Water, fuel, food, and medicine are scarce across the U.S. territory, and officials there are warning that people are dying for lack of resources. Can you put a price on helping people survive? It was amazing seeing Americans come together to help people in Texas and Florida during a crisis, so what is stopping us from helping this US territory? Always think to the Golden Rule, treat others the way you want to be treated. If you were in the same situation, you lost everything you had, you’re thirsty, starving, and possibly need medical attention, but because of limited help from surrounding nations, you may never get the help you need. Puerto Rico couldn’t control a hurricane devastating their nation, and furthering their problems. But the US can control the aid we give. It’s time to take action, help the families and children of Puerto Rico. Ease their suffering and despair. Do it for them, do it for you, or do it simply for humanity.


Huracán Maria


Comments


bottom of page